30 December 2010

New Year's Resolution I: Revisiting Old Slights.

Surfing around the internet, I found this from SE Cupp:
What’s your New Year’s resolution? — Bentley M.
Same as every year, Bentley M: Watch more TV, gain weight, exercise less, drink more, waste money, treat my friends with disdain, spend more time alone, help no one and squander my success. I’m always trying to do this, see, but it’s a lot harder than you’d think.
The joke here, of course, is that these are resolutions that can actually be met, as opposed to the more obvious resolutions that take effort and are hard.  It's a funny joke (if not original to Ms. Cupp).


It reminded me of this post from some blog I never heard of, taking issue with a comment I once made at Brothersjudd, to wit:
Is there anything scarier than a human being armed with a moral code that he can live up to without being a hypocrite?
The topic, of course, was atheism and morality, and I have to say that, revisiting this comment almost six years later, I really like it.  It's epigrammatic, witty and True.  It is the functionalist argument against atheism whittled down to its core.

The wonderful thing about the Haight Speech response is that it proves my other point about atheism; that it's a Christian heresy.

13 comments:

Peter said...

It really isn't very nice of you to be taunting Christian atheists during the holiday season.

Peter said...

OK, holiday's over. Let 'er rip!

Recusant said...

It's so good I might steal it. If I can remember it.

Hey Skipper said...

It is the functionalist argument against atheism whittled down to its core.

And here I thought it was an argument against human beings with moral codes they can live up to without being hypocrites.

Harry Eagar said...

I am not aware mow, as I was not six years ago, that there is an atheist mpral code that one can be sneaky about.

David said...

There isn't, which is sort of the point.

Hey Skipper said...

David:

You rarely confuse what and why.

David said...

Skipper: Do you think that they've never told a lie, or that they think that lying is moral?

Hey Skipper said...

David:

There's a word that's on the tip of my tongue.

anti ...

antimon ... no that's not it.

antinuc ... no, not quite.

Oh yeah.

Antinomian.

Now, if only I could remember the meaning.

Hey Skipper said...

Oh, and in answer to your question: No.

David said...

"Bingo," to coin a phrase. Atheism is a Christian heresy very much like Antinomianism, except in Atheism people believe that they need not follow the law because they are inherently good.

Hey Skipper said...

What is theism?

Hey Skipper said...

What is theism?