Dear Prudie,Every once in a while, when I'm in my car I find myself listening to Dr. Laura. Whenever this happens, I am struck anew by how mean and nasty she is to the callers, who have apparently never heard the show before, or are masochists. Now, radio shrink shows (and sob sister columns) are necessarily scams. The host pretends to offer advice and therapy in 30 second increments, but is really just using the caller's pain and perversion to attract listeners so she can sell advertising. Only Dr. Laura, though, makes it a point to tell her scummy callers that they are scum. As we can see from this letter to "Dear Prudence," it really should be a more widespread practice.
I just had my three-year anniversary with my boyfriend. He was married when we first met, and we eventually had a very brief affair before he left his wife. He has two children with her, whom I have a great relationship with and love very much. I am beginning to think it was a mistake and we rushed too quickly into getting serious. Now that we have settled into our life together (we bought a house), I find we have less and less in common and am starting to see that our long-term goals and dreams are vastly different. Thoughts of breaking up have crossed my mind. Although at the time I believed he left his wife because his marriage was over, I now know that I played a much greater role in bringing about the end of their marriage. I have so much guilt over how our relationship started and now feel even more guilt that I effectively stole someone else's life, a life that they wanted, and now I don't want it anymore. I also find it increasingly harder to deal with the fact that friends and family will always see me as the other woman or him as a scoundrel. I'm sure his ex would love to see our relationship fail as she hates my guts and I know that hearing about me from her children is torture. Sometimes I wish he would leave me and get back together with her. Am I entitled to familial happiness after what I did? I don't want to hurt him, and I especially don't want to hurt his children any more than I already have. I can't reach the decision to leave but am not happy staying. Is this my punishment for what I did?
30 September 2006
Give Dr. Kevorkian An Advice Column
Torture
This isn't the big torture post I mean to get to one of these days, but there is a point that doesn't get as much play as it should. When we first started collecting high value prisoners in Afghanistan, the military and CIA had to decide what they could do with them, interrogation wise. On the one hand, these prisoners had (potentially) lots of information we could use. On the other hand, and contrary to what you've heard, they were under orders to treat the prisoners humanely. So it was left up to the interrogators, in the first instance, to figure out what they could do.
The rule of thumb they came up with is that they could do to the high value prisoners those things that are done to American troops. They figured that the fact that we do it to ourselves means that it is not inhumane by definition. That's where almost all of the high-pressure "torture" techniques, including waterboarding, come from.
The rule of thumb they came up with is that they could do to the high value prisoners those things that are done to American troops. They figured that the fact that we do it to ourselves means that it is not inhumane by definition. That's where almost all of the high-pressure "torture" techniques, including waterboarding, come from.
29 September 2006
Sometimes The Hive Mind Is Stupid
Massachusetts has a law, dating from 1913, that people from out-of-state cannot get married in Massachusetts if their state of residence would not let them get married. Although I'm sure that this effects cousins or people with some other degree of consanguinity that may legally marry in Massachusetts but not in their own state, the statute almost certainly was passed due to concerns about miscegenation. It was, when passed, a bad law.
But now it has a new purpose: it stops same-sex couples from other states from coming into Massachusetts and getting married and then trying to have that marriage recognized in their own state, in effect exporting same-sex marriage. The Commonwealth has been pretty good about enforcing the statute and out-of-state couples have been denied marriage licenses in Massachusetts. Until today.
Today, the Massachusetts trial court held that two women from Rhode Island can get married in Massachusetts because the Massachusetts trial court couldn't find any Rhode Island law banning same-sex marriage. There can be no doubt that this is result oriented judging combined with willful blindness. In fact, I'm pretty sure that it is wrong as a matter of Massachusetts law and will be overturned on appeal. Remember that in the Goodridge case (instituting same-sex marriage) the same argument was made about Massachusetts law and the court rejected it. The word "marriage," said the court, means the joining of a man and a woman and necessarily excluded same-sex couples. The court went on to hold that the law excluding same-sex couples, by use of the word "marriage," violated the Massachusetts' constitution, but the will not make that decision for Rhode Island.
So, you ask yourself, if this case is not likely to survive the appellate process, why am I bothering to write about it?
Because the Goodridge decision, while good news for Ms. Goodridge and her wife (though they've since started divorce proceedings) was terrible news for the gay marriage movement and the Democratic Party. A court doing what we were always told a court would never do galvanized the right into sponsoring state referenda on gay marriage, the referenda drew voters like flies, and while they were there they voted for Republicans. Still, we were told that this was an unnecessary over-reaction. No other state was going to be forced to recognize gay marriage because of Massachusetts' decision. Now we see that there can be no assurance on that point either: is anyone 100% certain that a couple, validly married in Massachusetts, will be held to be unmarried by a Rhode Island court?
How much damage to the gay-marriage movement and the Democratic Party will be done by a clear example of a Massachusetts court going out of its way to try to spread gay marriage to Rhode Island? If given their druthers, is there any question that the movement generally and the Democratic Party specifically would wish that this hadn't come up five weeks before the election.
But now it has a new purpose: it stops same-sex couples from other states from coming into Massachusetts and getting married and then trying to have that marriage recognized in their own state, in effect exporting same-sex marriage. The Commonwealth has been pretty good about enforcing the statute and out-of-state couples have been denied marriage licenses in Massachusetts. Until today.
Today, the Massachusetts trial court held that two women from Rhode Island can get married in Massachusetts because the Massachusetts trial court couldn't find any Rhode Island law banning same-sex marriage. There can be no doubt that this is result oriented judging combined with willful blindness. In fact, I'm pretty sure that it is wrong as a matter of Massachusetts law and will be overturned on appeal. Remember that in the Goodridge case (instituting same-sex marriage) the same argument was made about Massachusetts law and the court rejected it. The word "marriage," said the court, means the joining of a man and a woman and necessarily excluded same-sex couples. The court went on to hold that the law excluding same-sex couples, by use of the word "marriage," violated the Massachusetts' constitution, but the will not make that decision for Rhode Island.
So, you ask yourself, if this case is not likely to survive the appellate process, why am I bothering to write about it?
Because the Goodridge decision, while good news for Ms. Goodridge and her wife (though they've since started divorce proceedings) was terrible news for the gay marriage movement and the Democratic Party. A court doing what we were always told a court would never do galvanized the right into sponsoring state referenda on gay marriage, the referenda drew voters like flies, and while they were there they voted for Republicans. Still, we were told that this was an unnecessary over-reaction. No other state was going to be forced to recognize gay marriage because of Massachusetts' decision. Now we see that there can be no assurance on that point either: is anyone 100% certain that a couple, validly married in Massachusetts, will be held to be unmarried by a Rhode Island court?
How much damage to the gay-marriage movement and the Democratic Party will be done by a clear example of a Massachusetts court going out of its way to try to spread gay marriage to Rhode Island? If given their druthers, is there any question that the movement generally and the Democratic Party specifically would wish that this hadn't come up five weeks before the election.
28 September 2006
Life In Northampton
A story on the front page of the local newspaper sums up life in Northampton:
Taking their art to the streets -- Northampton policy about-face allows art sales on city sidewalks (Dan Crowley, Daily Hampshire Gazette, 9/28906)
That the Board Of Public Works asked the City's lawyer for her opinion, got it, didn't like it and then asked the ACLU does show some initiative. If they only showed that much initiative filling pot holes, or fixing the bridge that lost its railing last year. I'm sure they'll get right to it, once they move past the trivial point of defining "art."
What I'm a little curious about is how they expect this new regulation to work. The heart of the First Amendment is that the government cannot treat speech differently based on its content. On the other hand, commercial speech has less protection than noncommercial speech. But all this art is, by definition, for sale. If the same picture is painted on two pieces of cloth, one of which is framed and the other of which is a t-shirt, is the first saleable but not the second? Is scrawling "War Is Not The Answer" art if it's on canvass but crafts if it's on polymer clay earrings? What is "fine art" and how is the cop on the beat supposed to know?
Apparently, all the answers are here: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.
Taking their art to the streets -- Northampton policy about-face allows art sales on city sidewalks (Dan Crowley, Daily Hampshire Gazette, 9/28906)
The Heresy Collective [Warning: Sound], and perhaps a slew of other artists, will soon be allowed to sell their artwork on the city's streets, according to public works officials.That a bunch of low-life no-talent artists group together and call themselves the "Heresy Collective" we can pass off without much comment. They're really sticking it to the man, man.
In a precedent-setting move, Robert C. Reckman, chairman of the Board of Public Works, said Wednesday that the board planned to develop a new policy paving the way for the street sale of 'fine arts.'
'We believe there is a strong constitutional argument that the sale of fine art by the artist is protected by the First Amendment,' Reckman told seven of the collective's nine young members at Wednesday's board meeting.
Reckman added that 'only fine arts, such as original painting, prints, sculpture and photography' would be covered, not 'goods, wares, and other merchandise in the normal sense.'
'We do not believe that this protection extends to crafts or decorative arts in this context,' he said....
Earlier this month, city attorney Janet Sheppard issued a memo to the board stating that, in her opinion, the sale of art, on all public streets and sidewalks in the city, including Main Street, was not allowed under the city ordinances or the Constitution.
Board of Public Works members then asked for an opinion from Northampton lawyer William C. Newman, director of the western regional office of the American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts....
The Heresy Collective's members said they looked forward to working with the board, and were excited to see the city backing artists. But they also expressed several concerns, including how public works officials might define 'fine arts.' In addition to paintings, drawings, and literature, the collective creates and sells original recorded music, which some of its members consider art.
That the Board Of Public Works asked the City's lawyer for her opinion, got it, didn't like it and then asked the ACLU does show some initiative. If they only showed that much initiative filling pot holes, or fixing the bridge that lost its railing last year. I'm sure they'll get right to it, once they move past the trivial point of defining "art."
What I'm a little curious about is how they expect this new regulation to work. The heart of the First Amendment is that the government cannot treat speech differently based on its content. On the other hand, commercial speech has less protection than noncommercial speech. But all this art is, by definition, for sale. If the same picture is painted on two pieces of cloth, one of which is framed and the other of which is a t-shirt, is the first saleable but not the second? Is scrawling "War Is Not The Answer" art if it's on canvass but crafts if it's on polymer clay earrings? What is "fine art" and how is the cop on the beat supposed to know?
Apparently, all the answers are here: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.
Things That Make You Go, "What The F..."
Dropping my daughter off at Temple this afternoon, I saw a car in the parking lot with the Massachusetts license plate "RAMALA." I can't decide if it is in honor of this Ramala or that and, in either case, what that person is doing in the Temple parking lot. (For those concerned that the first Ramallah has two "L"s and an "H", Massachusetts vanity plates only have six characters.)
27 September 2006
Things On Which I've Meant To Blog
Letting intention substitute for the act, I have been meaning to blog on the following:
1. The really hilarious conspiracy theories on DU, etc., that George Bush is responsible for falling gas prices. If I remember correctly, when prices were heading up, John Kerry thundered that George Bush should go to his friends in the oil bidness and talk them into dropping the price of gasoline.
2. The line between torture and good interrogation tactics. How much does it have to do with the end being pursued? Torture in order to extract a confession for use in court is bad. Coercion to get actionable military information is good.
3. And while we're at it, what to make of the argument that torture never results in good information. Is there any example in which that's the way the world works? What are they saying about all the various governments who have used torture, broadly defined? That they are just sadists, completely uninterested in the truth? My impression was that the meme from World War II to 9/11 was that everyone breaks eventually, so whenever an operative was captured you had to assume that everything they knew would soon be known to the enemy. When people say that the prisoner will say anything to stop the torture, that's true as far as it goes. But it can only work as a result of bad technique on the part of the interrogators. You need to start with broad questions that don't communicate much information to the prisoner and you need to ask at least some questions to which you know the answer.
4. Finally, a lovely piece in USA Today a few days ago arguing that lower gas prices might stoke inflation. Of course, higher gas prices are also said to stoke inflation. The sheer ignorance of almost everyone about what inflation is (a general increase in prices caused by an increase in the money supply relative to real value) is astonishing. As Milton Friedman said, inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon. It cannot be caused by an increase or decrease in commodity prices. (Which is not to say that changes in oil prices don't show up in the prices for a lot of other products that incorporate petroleum one way or another. They do. But that's not inflation (by definition). That's the price mechanism at work, signaling that we ought to shift away from, or to, the effected products.)
1. The really hilarious conspiracy theories on DU, etc., that George Bush is responsible for falling gas prices. If I remember correctly, when prices were heading up, John Kerry thundered that George Bush should go to his friends in the oil bidness and talk them into dropping the price of gasoline.
2. The line between torture and good interrogation tactics. How much does it have to do with the end being pursued? Torture in order to extract a confession for use in court is bad. Coercion to get actionable military information is good.
3. And while we're at it, what to make of the argument that torture never results in good information. Is there any example in which that's the way the world works? What are they saying about all the various governments who have used torture, broadly defined? That they are just sadists, completely uninterested in the truth? My impression was that the meme from World War II to 9/11 was that everyone breaks eventually, so whenever an operative was captured you had to assume that everything they knew would soon be known to the enemy. When people say that the prisoner will say anything to stop the torture, that's true as far as it goes. But it can only work as a result of bad technique on the part of the interrogators. You need to start with broad questions that don't communicate much information to the prisoner and you need to ask at least some questions to which you know the answer.
4. Finally, a lovely piece in USA Today a few days ago arguing that lower gas prices might stoke inflation. Of course, higher gas prices are also said to stoke inflation. The sheer ignorance of almost everyone about what inflation is (a general increase in prices caused by an increase in the money supply relative to real value) is astonishing. As Milton Friedman said, inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon. It cannot be caused by an increase or decrease in commodity prices. (Which is not to say that changes in oil prices don't show up in the prices for a lot of other products that incorporate petroleum one way or another. They do. But that's not inflation (by definition). That's the price mechanism at work, signaling that we ought to shift away from, or to, the effected products.)
25 September 2006
A No Win Situation
Senator Allen is, I'm sure, unhappy to see an AP story entitled Sen. Allen Denies Using Racial Slur. Saying it would be bad, denying it is bad, being accused of it is bad.
24 September 2006
Guess The Role Model
Using only this sentence fragment from Slate, guess who is writer/director/actor Zach Braff's role model: he created a role that requires Natalie Portman to fall in love with him.
23 September 2006
In The 21st Century, Winners Don't Die Of Typhoid
France Looks Into bin Laden Death Report (AP, 9/23/06)
French defense ministry on Saturday called for an internal investigation of the leak of an intelligence document that raises the possibility that Osama bin Laden may have died of typhoid in Pakistan a month ago but said the report of the death remained unverified.Or hide in a cave while their death is misreported.
22 September 2006
From The BrothersJudd Archives: CALL ME ISHMAEL
Today is the first day of Rosh Hashanah. Tomorrow's Torah reading relates the sacrifice of Isaac. Today's reading relates what we might call the sacrifice of Ishmael.
Genesis 21:1-34
In the Quran, the two stories are collapsed.
Quran, Sura 37:
The Torah story is the more psychologically complex. Sarah demands that Hagar and Ishmael be banished, but only after Isaac is born. Is that because she fears for Isaac's birth-right? Is it that she always hated Hagar and Ishmael, but knew that Abraham would not allow his only son, even one who's mother is a slave, to be exiled? With the impact of feminism on Jewish worship (which has been surprisingly beneficial), the more modern interpretation is that Sarah is a prophetess in her own right and that she is announcing G-d's will. Abraham, arguably strong in the story of Isaac's sacrifice, is shown in this story as weak and vacillating. G-d is shown as steadfast, holding on to His promises to Abraham even in unusual circumstances, which makes the story important for Christian theology. I was struck today by the passivity shown by Hagar and Ishmael, who from all the story shows, go into the desert with all the proper submission that Islam could wish. In the Torah story, though, Hagar and Ishmael are not sustained by their faith. Hagar loses hope and cannot bear to watch Ishmael die.
The Sura does not mention either Sarah or Hagar, and feminism has yet to come to Islam. Sura 37, much more than the story in Genesis, is about submission. Ishmael is told about his father's dream requiring his sacrifice. Ishmael, true to the theme of submission to Allah's will, agrees immediately and readies himself. On the other hand, as Islam rejects the possibility that Allah will not advocate evil, even as a test, tradition holds that the dream comes from Satan. In the two Torah portions dealing with the sacrifices of Abraham's sons, there is no question but that G-d is acting directly, nor is it at all clear (for Ishmael it is not even suggested) that this was only a test. In each telling, the son to be sacrificed is, at the time, the only son. In the Quran, Isaac has not yet been born, while in the Torah Isaac's sacrifice occurs after Ishmael has been banished. Each tradition is determined to show that its patriarch was special in his father's eyes and that each, being most-beloved of Abraham, was the only fitting sacrifice.
Now let's pretend for a moment that we are not dealing with sacred texts inspired by the Divine. Where does this leave us in the middle east? The great crusade on which we are currently embarked is to destabilize the middle east by establishing democracy. Through democracy and other inducements, we hope to settle the conflicts inflicting this part of the world. But while diplomats can work on territorial grievances, reparations and the settling of old scores where "old" means within the last fifty years, diplomats can do nothing to settle the problem of a sibling rivalry three thousand years old.
Judaism, with the fall of the second Temple and the diaspora, has been through a reformation. The priestly cast is gone and the age of rabbinic Judaism, in which it is sufficient to simply read about the Temple rituals, has come. Christianity has gone through its own reformation and the relationship between G-d and man and that between man and the church, has changed even in the Catholic Church. Islam, alone, has not been reformed. And yet Islam must be reformed if it is to take its place next to the other two great Abrahamic religions. A good place to start is at the beginning. Both the Torah and the Quran make clear that Abraham, though a problematic father figure, loved his two sons. Perhaps we need to stop caring, quite so much, which son he, and His G-d, loved more.
To all our friends at BrothersJudd, a happy and healthy new year, and a blessed Ramadan.
Posted by David Cohen at October 4, 2005 10:55 PM
Genesis 21:1-34
1 The Lord took note of Sarah as He had promised, and the Lord did for Sarah as He had spoken. 2 Sarah conceived and bore a son to Abraham in his old age, at the set time of which God had spoken. 3 Abraham gave his newborn son, whom Sarah had borne him, the name of Isaac. 4 And when his son Isaac was eight days old, Abraham circumcised him, as God had commanded him. 5 Now Abraham was a hundred years old when his son Isaac was born to him. 6 Sarah said, "God has brought me laughter; everyone who hears will laugh with me." 7 And she added,
"Who would have said to Abraham
That Sarah would suckle children!
Yet I have borne a son in his old age."
8 The child grew up and was weaned, and Abraham held a great feast on the day that Isaac was weaned.
9 Sarah saw the son whom Hagar the Egyptian had borne to Abraham playing. 10 She said to Abraham, "Cast out that slave-woman and her son, for the son of that slave shall not share in the inheritance with my son Isaac." 11 The matter distressed Abraham greatly, for it concerned a son of his. 12 But God said to Abraham, "Do not be distressed over the boy or your slave; whatever Sarah tells you, do as she says, for it is through Isaac that offspring shall be continued for you. 13 As for the son of the slave-woman, I will make a nation of him, too, for he is your seed."
14 Early next morning Abraham took some bread and a skin of water, and gave them to Hagar. He placed them over her shoulder, together with the child, and sent her away. And she wandered about in the wilderness of Beer-sheba. 15 When the water was gone from the skin, she left the child under one of the bushes, 16 and went and sat down at a distance, a bowshot away; for she thought, "Let me not look on as the child dies." And sitting thus afar, she burst into tears.
17 God heard the cry of the boy, and an angel of God called to Hagar from heaven and said to her, "What troubles you, Hagar? Fear not, for God has heeded the cry of the boy where he is. 18 Come, lift up the boy and hold him by the hand, for I will make a great nation of him." 19 Then God opened her eyes and she saw a well of water. She went and filled the skin with water, and let the boy drink. 20 God was with the boy and he grew up; he dwelt in the wilderness and became a bowman. 21 He lived in the wilderness of Paran; and his mother got a wife for him from the land of Egypt.
In the Quran, the two stories are collapsed.
Quran, Sura 37:
[37:100][Abraham said] "My Lord, grant me righteous children."In the Jewish tradition, the great nation that Ishmael goes on to father is the Arab nation and, in the Islamic tradition, Mohammad is one of his descendants. What are we to make of the fact that each branch of the family claims that it was their ancestor that was offered to G-d as a sacrifice? It seems an odd sort of honor.
[37:101] We gave him good news of a good child.
Satanic Dream
[37:102] When he grew enough to work with him, he said, "My son, I see in a dream that I am sacrificing you. What do you think?" He said, "O my father, do what you are commanded to do. You will find me, GOD willing, patient."
[37:103] They both submitted, and he put his forehead down (to sacrifice him).
God Intervenes to Save Abraham and Ismail
[37:104] We called him: "O Abraham.
[37:105] "You have believed the dream." We thus reward the righteous.
[37:106] That was an exacting test indeed.
[37:107] We ransomed (Ismail) by substituting an animal sacrifice.
[37:108] And we preserved his history for subsequent generations.
[37:109] Peace be upon Abraham.
[37:110] We thus reward the righteous.
[37:111] He is one of our believing servants.
Birth of Isaac
[37:112] Then we gave him the good news about the birth of Isaac, to be one of the righteous prophets.
[37:113] We blessed him and Isaac. Among their descendants, some are righteous, and some are wicked transgressors.
The Torah story is the more psychologically complex. Sarah demands that Hagar and Ishmael be banished, but only after Isaac is born. Is that because she fears for Isaac's birth-right? Is it that she always hated Hagar and Ishmael, but knew that Abraham would not allow his only son, even one who's mother is a slave, to be exiled? With the impact of feminism on Jewish worship (which has been surprisingly beneficial), the more modern interpretation is that Sarah is a prophetess in her own right and that she is announcing G-d's will. Abraham, arguably strong in the story of Isaac's sacrifice, is shown in this story as weak and vacillating. G-d is shown as steadfast, holding on to His promises to Abraham even in unusual circumstances, which makes the story important for Christian theology. I was struck today by the passivity shown by Hagar and Ishmael, who from all the story shows, go into the desert with all the proper submission that Islam could wish. In the Torah story, though, Hagar and Ishmael are not sustained by their faith. Hagar loses hope and cannot bear to watch Ishmael die.
The Sura does not mention either Sarah or Hagar, and feminism has yet to come to Islam. Sura 37, much more than the story in Genesis, is about submission. Ishmael is told about his father's dream requiring his sacrifice. Ishmael, true to the theme of submission to Allah's will, agrees immediately and readies himself. On the other hand, as Islam rejects the possibility that Allah will not advocate evil, even as a test, tradition holds that the dream comes from Satan. In the two Torah portions dealing with the sacrifices of Abraham's sons, there is no question but that G-d is acting directly, nor is it at all clear (for Ishmael it is not even suggested) that this was only a test. In each telling, the son to be sacrificed is, at the time, the only son. In the Quran, Isaac has not yet been born, while in the Torah Isaac's sacrifice occurs after Ishmael has been banished. Each tradition is determined to show that its patriarch was special in his father's eyes and that each, being most-beloved of Abraham, was the only fitting sacrifice.
Now let's pretend for a moment that we are not dealing with sacred texts inspired by the Divine. Where does this leave us in the middle east? The great crusade on which we are currently embarked is to destabilize the middle east by establishing democracy. Through democracy and other inducements, we hope to settle the conflicts inflicting this part of the world. But while diplomats can work on territorial grievances, reparations and the settling of old scores where "old" means within the last fifty years, diplomats can do nothing to settle the problem of a sibling rivalry three thousand years old.
Judaism, with the fall of the second Temple and the diaspora, has been through a reformation. The priestly cast is gone and the age of rabbinic Judaism, in which it is sufficient to simply read about the Temple rituals, has come. Christianity has gone through its own reformation and the relationship between G-d and man and that between man and the church, has changed even in the Catholic Church. Islam, alone, has not been reformed. And yet Islam must be reformed if it is to take its place next to the other two great Abrahamic religions. A good place to start is at the beginning. Both the Torah and the Quran make clear that Abraham, though a problematic father figure, loved his two sons. Perhaps we need to stop caring, quite so much, which son he, and His G-d, loved more.
To all our friends at BrothersJudd, a happy and healthy new year, and a blessed Ramadan.
Posted by David Cohen at October 4, 2005 10:55 PM
From the BrothersJudd Archives: HUMAN SACRIFICE: ABOMINATION OR SECRET TO SUCCESS (For AOG)
Genesis 22
Judges 11
Leviticus
Deuteronomy
Here we have, at the heart of Rosh Hashanah, one of the foundation stones of western civilization -- the offering of Isaac. As we discussed yesterday, note the importance to the story that Isaac is considered Abraham's only son. Ishmael has been banished and is no longer Abraham's son. G-d's relationship descends from Abraham through Isaac to Israel.
The fact that Isaac is Abraham's only son -- and when G-d says only, He means now and forever -- is one of the odd things about this story. G-d has promised that Abraham's descendants will be a mighty nation, more numerous than the stars. How can that promise come true if Isaac, Abraham's only son, is sacrificed? Abraham, though a notoriously stiff-necked man, never argues with G-d but goes along. We have to suspect, don't we, that Abraham has figured out the "test." But, of course, G-d knows that Abraham knows and Abraham knows that G-d knows. So what kind of test is this? In Temple today, the Rabbi brought up an interesting suggestion: the test is not whether Abraham is willing to sacrifice Isaac. What sort of test is that? Given the time, given the mores, given the demands of neighboring gods, given that G-d is G-d, why wouldn't Abraham comply? The real test, suggested the Rabbi, was whether Abraham -- who had steeled his nerves to the task, who had traveled for days, who had bound his son and raised the knife -- would stop when told to stop. He passed that test. If he had failed, then G-d's promises would have been forfeit. As he passed, the promises remained.
But what about Jephthah and his vow that "whatever comes out of the door of my house to meet me when I return in triumph from the Ammonites will be the LORD's, and I will sacrifice it as a burnt offering." Given the story of Isaac, given the law making human sacrifice an abomination, why would he make such a vow, why would G-d reward it and how could he (or He) see it carried out. There are important lessons in Jephthah's story about rash vows and what it means to pray and see a prayer seemingly answered. If G-d intended the Gileadites to triumph, should He have changed His mind because of Jephthah's vow? Obviously, we must be circumspect in the promises we make, to each other and to G-d.
On the other hand, the most likely explanation for the story of Jephthah's daughter is that it is misunderstood. Jephthah could not have gotten either the people of Gilead or the Priests to go along with a human sacrifice. Moreover, the story seems oddly interested in the state of his daughters virginity for a story about human sacrifice. What seems to be going on here is that Jephthah vowed that whatever came out to greet him would either be consecrated to G-d or, if appropriate, be sacrificed as a burnt offering. In ancient Israel, a person could be consecrated to G-d, cloistered and would not thereafter marry. This makes sense of the daughter's response to Jephthah's news ("Give me two months to roam the hills and weep with my friends, because I will never marry") as well as the ending of the story, "And she was a virgin" as opposed to "And she was a burnt offering."
Posted by David Cohen at October 5, 2005 11:39 PM
MORE: I keep meaning to email my Rabbi for his notes on a particularly nice sermon he gave a few weeks ago. One of the points he made is that it is entirely appropriate, when you come to a particularly troubling biblical passage, to say "it can't really mean that."
Abraham Tested
1 Some time later God tested Abraham. He said to him, "Abraham!" "Here I am," he replied.
2 Then God said, "Take your son, your only son, Isaac, whom you love, and go to the region of Moriah. Sacrifice him there as a burnt offering on one of the mountains I will tell you about."
3 Early the next morning Abraham got up and saddled his donkey. He took with him two of his servants and his son Isaac. When he had cut enough wood for the burnt offering, he set out for the place God had told him about. 4 On the third day Abraham looked up and saw the place in the distance. 5 He said to his servants, "Stay here with the donkey while I and the boy go over there. We will worship and then we will come back to you."
6 Abraham took the wood for the burnt offering and placed it on his son Isaac, and he himself carried the fire and the knife. As the two of them went on together, 7 Isaac spoke up and said to his father Abraham, "Father?" "Yes, my son?" Abraham replied. "The fire and wood are here," Isaac said, "but where is the lamb for the burnt offering?"
8 Abraham answered, "God himself will provide the lamb for the burnt offering, my son." And the two of them went on together.
9 When they reached the place God had told him about, Abraham built an altar there and arranged the wood on it. He bound his son Isaac and laid him on the altar, on top of the wood. 10 Then he reached out his hand and took the knife to slay his son. 11 But the angel of the LORD called out to him from heaven, "Abraham! Abraham!" "Here I am," he replied.
12 "Do not lay a hand on the boy," he said. "Do not do anything to him. Now I know that you fear God, because you have not withheld from me your son, your only son."
13 Abraham looked up and there in a thicket he saw a ram [a] caught by its horns. He went over and took the ram and sacrificed it as a burnt offering instead of his son. 14 So Abraham called that place The LORD Will Provide. And to this day it is said, "On the mountain of the LORD it will be provided."
Judges 11
29 Then the Spirit of the LORD came upon Jephthah. He crossed Gilead and Manasseh, passed through Mizpah of Gilead, and from there he advanced against the Ammonites. 30 And Jephthah made a vow to the LORD : "If you give the Ammonites into my hands, 31 whatever comes out of the door of my house to meet me when I return in triumph from the Ammonites will be the LORD's, and I will sacrifice it as a burnt offering."
32 Then Jephthah went over to fight the Ammonites, and the LORD gave them into his hands. 33 He devastated twenty towns from Aroer to the vicinity of Minnith, as far as Abel Keramim. Thus Israel subdued Ammon.
34 When Jephthah returned to his home in Mizpah, who should come out to meet him but his daughter, dancing to the sound of tambourines! She was an only child. Except for her he had neither son nor daughter. 35 When he saw her, he tore his clothes and cried, "Oh! My daughter! You have made me miserable and wretched, because I have made a vow to the LORD that I cannot break."
36 "My father," she replied, "you have given your word to the LORD. Do to me just as you promised, now that the LORD has avenged you of your enemies, the Ammonites. 37 But grant me this one request," she said. "Give me two months to roam the hills and weep with my friends, because I will never marry."
38 "You may go," he said. And he let her go for two months. She and the girls went into the hills and wept because she would never marry. 39 After the two months, she returned to her father and he did to her as he had vowed. And she was a virgin. From this comes the Israelite custom 40 that each year the young women of Israel go out for four days to commemorate the daughter of Jephthah the Gileadite.
Leviticus
18:21 And thou shalt not let any of thy seed pass through the fire to Molech, neither shalt thou profane the name of thy God: I am the LORD.
20:2 Again, thou shalt say to the children of Israel, Whosoever he be of the children of Israel, or of the strangers that sojourn in Israel, that giveth any of his seed unto Molech; he shall surely be put to death: the people of the land shall stone him with stones.
Deuteronomy
12:30 Take heed to thyself that thou be not snared by following them, after that they be destroyed from before thee; and that thou inquire not after their gods, saying, How did these nations serve their gods? even so will I do likewise.
12:31 Thou shalt not do so unto the LORD thy God: for every abomination to the LORD, which he hateth, have they done unto their gods; for even their sons and their daughters they have burnt in the fire to their gods.
Here we have, at the heart of Rosh Hashanah, one of the foundation stones of western civilization -- the offering of Isaac. As we discussed yesterday, note the importance to the story that Isaac is considered Abraham's only son. Ishmael has been banished and is no longer Abraham's son. G-d's relationship descends from Abraham through Isaac to Israel.
The fact that Isaac is Abraham's only son -- and when G-d says only, He means now and forever -- is one of the odd things about this story. G-d has promised that Abraham's descendants will be a mighty nation, more numerous than the stars. How can that promise come true if Isaac, Abraham's only son, is sacrificed? Abraham, though a notoriously stiff-necked man, never argues with G-d but goes along. We have to suspect, don't we, that Abraham has figured out the "test." But, of course, G-d knows that Abraham knows and Abraham knows that G-d knows. So what kind of test is this? In Temple today, the Rabbi brought up an interesting suggestion: the test is not whether Abraham is willing to sacrifice Isaac. What sort of test is that? Given the time, given the mores, given the demands of neighboring gods, given that G-d is G-d, why wouldn't Abraham comply? The real test, suggested the Rabbi, was whether Abraham -- who had steeled his nerves to the task, who had traveled for days, who had bound his son and raised the knife -- would stop when told to stop. He passed that test. If he had failed, then G-d's promises would have been forfeit. As he passed, the promises remained.
But what about Jephthah and his vow that "whatever comes out of the door of my house to meet me when I return in triumph from the Ammonites will be the LORD's, and I will sacrifice it as a burnt offering." Given the story of Isaac, given the law making human sacrifice an abomination, why would he make such a vow, why would G-d reward it and how could he (or He) see it carried out. There are important lessons in Jephthah's story about rash vows and what it means to pray and see a prayer seemingly answered. If G-d intended the Gileadites to triumph, should He have changed His mind because of Jephthah's vow? Obviously, we must be circumspect in the promises we make, to each other and to G-d.
On the other hand, the most likely explanation for the story of Jephthah's daughter is that it is misunderstood. Jephthah could not have gotten either the people of Gilead or the Priests to go along with a human sacrifice. Moreover, the story seems oddly interested in the state of his daughters virginity for a story about human sacrifice. What seems to be going on here is that Jephthah vowed that whatever came out to greet him would either be consecrated to G-d or, if appropriate, be sacrificed as a burnt offering. In ancient Israel, a person could be consecrated to G-d, cloistered and would not thereafter marry. This makes sense of the daughter's response to Jephthah's news ("Give me two months to roam the hills and weep with my friends, because I will never marry") as well as the ending of the story, "And she was a virgin" as opposed to "And she was a burnt offering."
Posted by David Cohen at October 5, 2005 11:39 PM
MORE: I keep meaning to email my Rabbi for his notes on a particularly nice sermon he gave a few weeks ago. One of the points he made is that it is entirely appropriate, when you come to a particularly troubling biblical passage, to say "it can't really mean that."
Celebrate International Web Day
You've all seen it elsewhere I'm sure, but just a reminder that, until November, the Royal Society has put all of its publications since 1655 on-line for free.
Happy Anniversary Of The Creation Of The World
It's Arev Rosh Hashonah and we've got 14 people coming to the house tomorrow, so I might be a little scarce. Here's a typically pompous and overly earnest comment from BrothersJudd to tide you over:
Oh, where to start...
In the beginning...
People of faith believe that there are two paths to knowledge: through perception and through faith. I know that there is a computer on my desk. I know that G-d exists. Materialists believe that the only path to true knowledge is through perception, and that the existence of my computer is a fact because I directly perceive it, while G-d's existence is not a fact because faith is not a legitimate path to knowledge. To people of faith, this attempt to give to perception a privileged position unattainable by faith is startling. It is as if a deaf man insisted that sound did not exist because he could not see it, or a blind man insisted that color did not exist because he could not smell it.
In practice, of course, no one insists that only those things that are directly perceived can be known. If enough people say that they have gone to Yellowstone and have seen hot water shooting out of the ground every hour or so, we accept that as a fact, despite not having perceived it, or anything like it, ourselves. The blind and the deaf accept that sight and hearing exist, because so many others tell them so, and much that they do perceive is otherwise inexplicable.
And yet the materialist, living amidst billions who claim to have perceived Truth through faith, living next to the sometimes quite concrete testimony of dead billions more, and living with the otherwise inexplicable mystery of the Beginning of material existence, insist that only their senses count and that if they cannot perceive access faith, it cannot exist. There are none so blind as those who will not see.
Yet, that is not entirely their fault.
Once a fact is known -- that G-d exists, or that He created the Earth, or that fossils have been found of animals that do not currently exist -- all we have with which to deal with that fact is our reason. Here is the tricky part even for those who accept faith as a means of cognition: what role does faith play in the manipulation of facts, regardless of how they are known. The answers to this question are all over the lot. Some believe the Bible to be the inerrent Word of G-d, accepting six days, Eve from Adam's rib, a great flood and the loaves and the fishes as a report of what would have been directly perceived, if they had been present to witness events. Others see G-d as starter, setting the race in motion but otherwise uninvolved. The majority take the most difficult route to justify, as we pick and choose between faith and perception. If a blind man heard such disparate reports of a sunset, he too might doubt sight, although he would be equally wrong.
Here we sit, then, with each side by now too wedded to its conclusions to allow for constructive reasoned discourse. Is there a path out of the morass? Probably not, but I'm willing to give it a (necessarily solipsistic) try.
There are certain things that both faith and reason tell me. I exist. Existence had a beginning. Reason can tell me nothing about conditions prior to the beginning of existence. My faith, perception, knowledge and reasoning are limited and imperfect.
What, then, can I conclude from these truths. First, that I can conclude nothing with certainty. The fact of my existence is the only certain fact available to me. Second, that both faith and reason push me to conclude (by which I can only mean "act as if") all the rest of you are sentient beings such as I am (though logic, of course, pushes the other way). Third, that both faith and reason push us to conclude (see above) that the physical world exists as we perceive it (though logic, again, pushes the other way). Fourth, that we can know is only a vague shadow of true existence; that all knowledge is but a metaphor that helps us navigate the unseen depths.
Each of us carries in our brain a model of the world. When we drive somewhere, or give directions, we are navigating our own model of the world. When we act in a particular way in order to cause another to respond as desired, we are navigating our own model of the world. When we add 2 to 2, we are navigating our own model of the world. When we plan for the future, we are navigating our own model of the world. When we worship or research, we are navigating our own model of the world. Every decision we make, every action we take, is made or taken -- not in the real world -- but in our model world. New knowledge comes only when the reality and our model diverge, at which point the model should change, but often doesn't.
Each of us has a model, and each model diverges from every other model to a greater or lesser extent. Models tend to be more alike within families, tribes or nations than between those groups. Some are more rigid than others, some more supple. But each model perceives reality though a slightly different lens. Different models can thus give us different insights into the nature of reality.
Perception and reason are inherently limited and flawed. They can see only part of the truth, and thus faith need not justify itself to reason. But, humans being humans, faith and knowledge are also limited. Each can give only part of the picture or, rather, a different picture of true existence. The one great advantage of faith, though, is that is requies acceptance that Truth exists outside of reality. To use Godel's model, faith is the statement that knows that it cannot be proved. Reason is "2+2=4", which believes itself to be true beyond proof. Reason denies its own model.
This is the rock on which the materialist falters. The materialist demands that only those things that can be perceived exist, but reason does not go so far. Reason also insists that atoms, say, existed before they could be perceived. The materialist must, therefore accept that those things exist that are capable of being perceived under the proper conditions, regardless of whether they are actually perceived. In other words, the materialist must punt on existence, substituting his model for perception -- exactly the crime of which he accuses the faithful.
Posted by: David Cohen at March 4, 2005 12:12 PM
21 September 2006
Fun With Photos
At the moment, Drudge has juxtaposed a 3.3 million year old skeleton with a picture of Barbra Streisand.
20 September 2006
Republicans May Be Evil, But We Are Certainly Brilliant
The Corner points to some yutz who writes that it is self-evidence that the Pope dissed Islam in order to help Republicans in the upcoming mid-term election:
Pope Provoked Muslim Rage To Help Bush and Republicans (Rob Kall, opednews.com)Leave to one side the obvious point that Rob Kall's vicious anti-Catholicism will not cause Catholic riots across the world. Let's just note that the Pope's statement about violence and Islam is untrue; that the ensuing riots will cause people to vote Republican; although Democrats could better protect us if there were a threat; that Republicans are questioning Democrats' patriotism by suggesting that they are blind to the obvious threat; and that there is no threat but just fear ginned up by Republicans because voters desperate for protection will vote Republican. (It is the song that never ends, it just goes on and on my friends ....)
Ratzinger is not stupid. Including the reference to the passage that has incited Muslim anger was no accident. It was a calculated, intentional strategy designed to help George Bush and the Republicans in the 2006 elections, just like the Catholic church systematically helped Bush and the Republicans in the 2004 elections, through Cardinals and Bishops who attacked Kerry....
To spell it out, it seems that the Pope intentionally drew an angry, violent, anti-Catholic, possibly anti-Christian response from Muslims on the street in the Arab world. This makes great TV -- burning the Pope or Christians in Effigy, threats to terror Bomb the Vatican and Catholic Churches. This is designed to raise the hackles of American Christians, to intensify the fear of Muslim terrorism, to boost the belief that there are 1.1 billion Muslims plotting against Americans.
There's no truth to these ideas, but there are millions of right wingers and some independents and dumbocrats who will go for this message hook, line and sinker.
Think I'll Go Buy Myself A Ford "Rhode Island"*
Oil drops below $60.00 a barrel.
_________________________________________________
*So called because it's the size of Rhode Island.
_________________________________________________
*So called because it's the size of Rhode Island.
19 September 2006
If The Election Were Held Today, I'd Be Very Surprised
Bruce Bartlett trots out the old line: If the election had been held six weeks ago, almost certainly they [Republicans] would have lost control of the House of Representatives and probably the Senate, as well. This reminds me of the arguments after 9/11 that, if this action or that had been taken, 9/11 wouldn't have happened. My favorite was that, if Ralph Nader had been elected, 9/11 wouldn't have happened because he had a plan to reinforce cockpit doors. Even if he did, and even if it became his top priority, it takes a spectacular leap of faith to believe that, eight months after his inaugural, four particular cockpit doors would have been reinforced, or that pre-9/11 flight crews would allow passengers and crew to be beheaded because they refused to open the doors.
But the real point is that, while we can reduce our vulnerabilities, we can't make ourselves invulnerable because the enemy is an actor, too. He will adopt to our new tactics, just as we adopt to his. If 9/11 had been made impossible, it would have taken some other form.
Similarly, if the election had been held six weeks ago, the president would have started making almost daily speeches 13 weeks ago. We would have adapted.
But the real point is that, while we can reduce our vulnerabilities, we can't make ourselves invulnerable because the enemy is an actor, too. He will adopt to our new tactics, just as we adopt to his. If 9/11 had been made impossible, it would have taken some other form.
Similarly, if the election had been held six weeks ago, the president would have started making almost daily speeches 13 weeks ago. We would have adapted.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)